A new structured thermal armour achieves liquid cooling above 1,000°C, overcoming challenge of Leidenfrost effect


Efficient cooling of hot surfaces is essential in different applications, from steel and aerospace industries to nuclear plants. But in physics, high temperature triggers the Leidenfrost effect, which makes liquid cooling on the hot surface ineffective. A research team led by scientists from City University of Hong Kong (CityU) has recently designed a structured thermal armour (STA) that achieves efficient liquid cooling even over 1,000°C, fundamentally solving a 266-year-old challenge presented by the Leidenfrost effect. This technology breakthrough can be applied in aero and space engines and beyond, including improving the safety and reliability of next-generation nuclear reactors.

The research has been led by Professor Wang Zuankai from CityU's Department of Mechanical Engineering (MNE), Professor David Quéré from the PSL Research University, France, and Professor Yu Jihong, Director of the International Center of Future Science, Jilin University and Senior Fellow of the Hong Kong Institute for Advanced Study at CityU.

The findings were published in the latest issue of the highly prestigious scientific journal Nature under the title “Inhibiting the Leidenfrost effect above 1,000 °C for sustained thermal cooling”. It was also highlighted in Nature News & Views.

A research team led by scientists from CityU has recently designed a structured thermal armour that achieves efficient liquid cooling even over 1,000°C. 


Cause of ineffective liquid cooling on hot surfaces

The Leidenfrost effect is a physical phenomenon discovered in 1756. A common example in our daily life is that a drop of water will quickly evaporate if it drops on an iron plate hotter than 100°C, the boiling point of water. But if the iron plate’s temperature reaches the “Leidenfrost point”, the water drop will roll around on the iron plate and evaporate gradually, “surviving” longer.

This is because when liquid drops on a surface significantly hotter than the boiling point, a thermal insulating vapour layer is produced at once between the liquid and the super-hot surface. As a result, the liquid is levitated, preventing the liquid-solid contact. This dramatically reduces heat transfer performances at high temperatures, making liquid cooling on the hot surface ineffective. This effect is most often detrimental and it has remained a historic challenge to suppress this effect.

leidenfrost effect
The STA successfully inhibits the occurrence of the Leidenfrost effect even up to 1,150 °C and achieves efficient liquid cooling. (City University of Hong Kong)

The CityU-led team solved this 266-year-old challenge by constructing the “structured thermal armour (STA)”, a multitextured new material with key elements that have contrasting thermal and geometrical properties. The rational design for the STA superimposes robust, highly thermally conductive, protruding steel pillars that serve as thermal bridges for promoting heat transfer; an embedded thermally insulating membrane designed to suck and evaporate the liquid; and underground U-shaped channels that evacuate the vapour.

leidenfrost effect
(a) A STA consists of an array of thick pillars acting as thermal bridges and holding an insulating superhydrophilic membrane that wicks the incoming liquid. This membrane is positioned to create channels that can evacuate the vapour (purple arrows shown in the bottom picture). (b) The membrane is made of nanometric silica fibres capable of resisting temperatures of up to approximately 1,200°C.(DOI number: 10.1038/s41586-021-04307-3)

The STA successfully inhibited the occurrence of the Leidenfrost effect up to 1,150 °C by transferring heat energy through liquid evaporation. Liquid superwetting that usually does not occur in extremely high temperatures was also observed. The research team discovered that STA achieves efficient and controllable cooling across the temperature range from 100°C to over 1,150°C, which is 600°C higher than previously attained.

leidenfrost effect
High-speed side and top views of water drops (dyed in orange) contacting Sample A (no membrane), Sample B (no channel) and Sample C (STA), all brought to 1,000 °C. Water on Sample C evaporates approximately 50 times faster than that on Samples A & B. (DOI number: 10.1038/s41586-021-04307-3)

The STA consists of pillars, thermally insulating membrane and U-shaped channels. The team built two control samples to investigate its performance, one with pillars and U-shaped channels and the other with a membrane but no channels. The team then observed what would happen when orange-dyed water drops on the surfaces of the three samples, which were all heated to 1,000°C. They found that water on STA was constantly pinned and sucked by the membrane, which led to a lifetime of 0.33s, approximately 50 times faster than the other two samples. This means that heat energy was transferred quickly by evaporation and cooled the surface.

STA can be flexible and apply to different surfaces

“This multidisciplinary research project is truly a breakthrough in science and engineering, since it mixes surface science, hydro- and aero-dynamics, thermal cooling, material science, physics, energy and engineering. Searching for novel strategies to address the liquid cooling of high-temperature surfaces has been one of the holy grails in thermal engineering since 1756. We are fortunate to fundamentally suppress the occurrence of the Leidenfrost effect and thereby provide a paradigm shift in liquid thermal cooling at extremely high temperatures, a mission that has remained uncharted to date,” said Professor Wang.

leidenfrost effect
(a) A smooth spheroidal piece of steel can be covered by thick pillars after wire cutting. Inserting a membrane in the pillars provides a curved STA. (b) STA can also be made on thin films of steel, which makes it flexible. The films can be welded onto flat or cylindrical solids. (c) The armours are tested to be able to provide rapid and efficient cooling, as evidenced by the drop in temperature (red data). Black data shows surface temperature of the object without STA.(DOI number: 10.1038/s41586-021-04307-3)

Professor Wang pointed out that current thermal cooling strategies under extremely high temperatures adopt air cooling measures rather than effective liquid cooling owing to the occurrence of the Leidenfrost effect, especially for applications in aero and space engines, next-generation nuclear reactors, and devices used in extremely high temperatures. Their technology breakthrough holds the potential to apply efficient liquid cooling of extremely high-temperature surfaces to nuclear plants and help prevent nuclear accidents.

“The designed STA can be fabricated to be flexible, eliminating the need for additional manufacturing, especially for those surfaces that are hard to be textured directly. This is why the STA possesses huge potential for practical applications,” added Professor Wang.

Professor Wang, Professor Quéré and Professor Yu are the corresponding authors of the paper. The first authors are Dr Jiang Mengnan and Dr Wang Yang from MNE.

The collaborators are Professor Pan Chin, Head, Dr Steven Wang, Assistant Professor, Zhang Huanhuan, Research Assistant, Liu Fayu and Li Yuchao, PhD students, from CityU’s MNE; and Professor To Suet and Du Hanheng, PhD student, from the Department of Industrial and Systems Engineering, Hong Kong Polytechnic University.

leidenfrost effect
Members of the CityU research team: (from left in front row) Dr Steven Wang, Professor Wang Zuankai, Professor Pan Chin, Dr Jiang Mengnan (from left in back row) Mr Liu Fayu and Mr Li Yuchao. (City University of Hong Kong)

The research was supported by the Research Grants Council of Hong Kong, the Tencent Foundation through the XPLORER PRIZE, the Hong Kong Innovation and Technology Commission, the National Natural Science Foundation of China and Programme of Introducing Talents of Discipline to Universities (the “111 Project”).

DOI number: 10.1038/s41586-021-04307-3

Newsletter Subscription: Research 

* indicates required

Areas of Interest 

Contact Information

Back to top